Execution Report <8> message – FIX 4.4 – FIX Dictionary

Structure | Related Messages

Description

The Execution Report <8> message is used to:

1. confirm the receipt of an order
2. confirm changes to an existing order (i.e. accept cancel and replace requests)
3. relay order status information
4. relay fill information on working orders
5. relay fill information on tradeable or restricted tradeable quotes
6. reject orders
7. report post-trade fees calculations associated with a trade

NOTE: Execution reports do not replace the end-of-day confirm. Execution reports are to be regarded only as replacements for the existing fill messages currently communicated via telephone.

NOTE: Individual Execution Reports are sent for each order on a New Order List <E>.

Each execution report contains two fields which are used to communicate both the current state of the order as understood by the broker (OrdStatus <39>) and the purpose of the message (ExecType <150>).

In an execution report the OrdStatus <39> is used to convey the current state of the order. If an order simultaneously exists in more than one order state, the value with highest precedence is the value that is reported in the OrdStatus <39> field. The order statuses are as follows (in highest to lowest precedence):

The ExecType <150> is used to identify the purpose of the Execution Report <8> message. To transmit a change in OrdStatus <39> for an order, the broker (sell side) should send an Execution Report <8> with the new OrdStatus <39> value in both the ExecType <150> AND the OrdStatus <39> fields to signify this message is changing the state of the order. The only exception to this rule is that when rejecting a cancel or cancel/replace request the Cancel Reject <9> message is used both to reject the request and to communicate the current OrdStatus <39>. An ExecType <150> of Pending Cancel or Pending Replace is used to indicate that a cancel or cancel/replace request is being processed. An ExecType <150> of Canceled or Replace is used to indicate that the cancel or cancel/replace request has been successfully processed.

Execution information (e.g. new partial fill or complete fill) should not be communicated in the same report as one which communicates other state changes (such as pending cancel, pending replace, canceled, replaced, accepted, done for day etc).

Any fills which occur and need to be communicated to the customer while an order is "pending" and waiting to achieve a new state (i.e. via a Order Cancel/Replace (aka Order Modification) Request <G>) must contain the "original" (current order prior to state change request) order parameters (i.e. ClOrdID <11>, OrderQty <38>, Price <44>, etc). These fills will cause the CumQty <14> and AvgPx <6> to be updated. An order cannot be considered replaced until it has been explicitly accepted and confirmed to have reached the replaced status via an execution report with ExecType <150> ='5' (Replace), at which time the effect of the replacement (ClOrdID <11>, new quantity or limit price etc) will be seen.

Requests to cancel or cancel/replace an order are only acted upon when there is an outstanding order quantity. Requests to replace the OrderQty <38> to a level less than the CumQty <14> will be interpreted by the broker as requests to stop executing the order. Requests to change price on a filled order will be rejected (see Order Cancel Reject <9> message type). The OrderQty <38>, CumQty <14>, LeavesQty <151>, and AvgPx <6> fields should be calculated to reflect the cumulative result of all versions of an order. For example, if partially filled order A were replaced by order B, the OrderQty <38>, CumQty <14>, LeavesQty <151>, and AvgPx <6> on order B's fills should represent the cumulative result of order A plus those on order B.

The general rule is: OrderQty <38> = CumQty <14> + LeavesQty <151>.

There can be exceptions to this rule when ExecType <150> and/or OrdStatus <39> are Canceled, DoneForTheDay (e.g. on a day order), Expired, Calculated, or Rejected in which case the order is no longer active and LeavesQty <151> could be 0.

Communication of information about a new fill is via the Execution report with ExecType <150> ='F' (Trade). Execution Reports with ExecType <150> ='H' (Trade Cancel) or 'G' (Trade Correct) are used to cancel or correct a previously modified execution report as follows:

• The ExecType <150> of Trade Cancel applies at the execution level and is used to cancel an execution which has been reported in error. The canceled execution will be identified in the ExecRefID <19> field.
  Note: ExecType <150> of Trade Cancel should not be used to cancel a previous ExecutionRpt with ExecType <150> of Trade Cancel (e.g. cannot cancel a cancel).
• The ExecType <150> of Trade Correct applies at the execution level and is used to modify an incorrectly reported fill. The incorrect execution will be identified in the ExecRefID <19> field. If a single execution is corrected more than once, ExecRefID <19> should refer to the ExecID <17> of the last corrected ExecutionRpt (same convention as ClOrdID <11> and OrigClOrdID <41>). To correct an ExecutionRpt which was previously canceled, an ExecutionRpt with ExecType <150> ='F' (Trade) should be sent (e.g. cannot send ExecType <150> ='G' (Trade Correct) for an ExecutionRpt with ExecType <150> ='H' (Trade Cancel)).
  Note: Data reported in the CumQty <14>, LeavesQty <151>, and AvgPx <6> fields represent the status of the order as of the time of the correction, not as of the time of the originally reported execution.

An ExecType <150> of Order Status indicates that the execution messages contains no new information, only summary information regarding order status. It is used, for example, in response to an Order Status request <H> message

See Appendix D: Order State Change Matrices for examples of key state changes, processing of cancel and cancel/replace requests, and for execution cancel/corrects.

An ExecutionRpt with ExecType <150> ='D' (Restated) represents an ExecutionRpt sent by the sellside communicating a change in the order or a restatement of the order's parameters without an electronic request from the customer. ExecRestatementReason <378> must be set. This is used for GT orders and corporate actions (see below), changes communicated verbally to the sellside either due to normal business practices or as an emergency measure when electronic systems are not available, repricing of orders by the sellside (such as making Sell Short orders compliant with uptick / downtick rules), or other reasons (Broker option). ExecRestatementReason <378> can also be used to communicate unsolicited cancels.

The field ClOrdID <11> is provided for institutions or buy-side brokers or intermediaries to affix an identification number to an order to coincide with internal systems. The OrderID <37> field is populated with the sell-side broker-generated order number (or fund manager-generated order number for CIVs). Unlike ClOrdID <11>/OrigClOrdID <41> which requires a chaining through Cancel/Replaces and Cancels, OrderID <37> and SecondaryOrderID <198> are not required to change through changes to an order.

The underlying business assumption of orders that can trade over multiple days, such as GTC and Good Till Date orders expiring on a future trading date (henceforth referred to as GT orders) is that a GT order that is not fully executed and has not been canceled and has not expired on a given day remains good for the broker to execute the following day. Note that the concept of "day" is determined by the market convention, which will be security specific. At the end of each trading day, once the order is no longer subject to execution, the broker may optionally send an Execution Report <8> with ExecType <150> ='3' (Done for Day). When the ExpireDate <432> or ExpireTime <126> of a Good Till Date order is reached, or a GTC order reaches a maximum age, the order is considered expired and the broker may optionally send an Execution Report <8> with ExecType <150> and OrdStatus <39> ='C' (Expired).

In handling GT orders, the OrderQty <38>, CumQty <14> and AvgPx <6> fields will represent the entirety of the order over all days. The fields DayOrderQty <424>, DayCumQty <425>, and DayAvgPx <426> can be used on days following the day of the first trade on a GT order. Prior to the start of business each day, for all GT orders that have partial fills on previous days, DayCumQty <425> and DayAvgPx <426> are set to zero, and DayOrderQty <424> becomes the LeavesQty <151>. The following relationship holds: DayOrderQty <424> = OrderQty <38> - (CumQty <14> - DayCumQty <425>). Since (CumQty <14> - DayCumQty <425>) represents the volume traded on all previous days, DayOrderQty <424> = OrderQty <38> - Volume traded on all previous days. Note that when changing the quantity of an order, both OrderQty <38> and DayOrderQty <424> will change. Requests to change or cancel an order will be made in terms of the total quantity for the order, not the quantity open today. For example, on an order where OrderQty <38>=10000 and 2000 shares trade during the previous days, a request to change OrderQty <38> to 15000 will mean that 13000 shares will be open. See Appendix D: Order State Change Matrices for examples of canceling and changing GT orders partially filled on previous days.

A Cancel on an execution (trade bust, ExecType <150> ='H' (Trade Cancel)) happening the same day of the trade will result in CumQty <14> and DayCumQty <425> each decreasing by the quantity busted, and LeavesQty <151> increasing by the quantity busted. OrderQty <38> and DayOrderQty <424> will remain unchanged. If the business rules allow for a trade bust to be reported on a later date than the trade being busted, the OrderQty <38> and DayCumQty <425> will remain unchanged, the LeavesQty <151> and DayOrderQty <424> will increase by the quantity busted, and the CumQty <14> will decrease by the quantity busted.

If bilaterally agreed between counterparties, a broker may wish to transmit a list of all open GT orders, permitting reconciliation of the open orders. Typically this transmission may occur at the end of the trading day or at the start of the following trading day. There is no expected response to such retransmission; in the event of a reconciliation problem this should be resolved manually or via the DK message. Assuming no corporate actions have occurred, the broker will send an Execution Report <8> with ExecType <150> ='D' (Restated) and ExecRestatementReason <378> ='1' (GT renewal / restatement (no corporate action)) for each open GT order. These Execution Reports may have DayCumQty <425> and DayAvgPx <426> restated to zero, and DayOrderQty <424> restated to LeavesQty <151> if the transmission occurs at the start of the following business day. The broker has the option of changing the OrderID <37> and SecondaryOrderID <198> fields, or leaving them unchanged. If they are changed, then the buy-side should use these new ID fields when sending Order Cancel Request <F>, Order Cancel/Replace Request <G>, and Order Status Request <H> messages.

In the case of a corporate action resulting in the adjustment of an open GT order, the broker will send an Execution Report <8> with ExecType <150> ='D' (Restated) and ExecRestatementReason <378> ='0' (GT Corporate action) with the order's state after the corporate action adjustment. In the case of stock splits, OrderQty <38>, CumQty <14>, AvgPx <6>, and LeavesQty <151> will be adjusted to reflect the order's state in terms of current quantity (e.g. shares), not pre-split quantity (e.g. shares). See Appendix D: Order State Change Matrices for examples of GT order restatement with and without a corporate action.

CIV orders to be executed by the fund manager do not use the TimeInForce <59> field and only a subset of OrdStatus <39> values are expected to be used. See VOLUME 7 - "PRODUCT: COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT VEHICLES" for the CIV-specific OrdStatus <39> values.

The Execution Report <8> message is also used for multileg instrument. See VOLUME 4 - "Use of the Execution Report for Multileg Instruments" for multileg-specific details.

Structure

Related Messages

• Reject <3>

• Order Cancel Reject <9>

• New Order Single <D>

• Order Cancel Request <F>

• Order Cancel/Replace Request <G>

• Order Status Request <H>

• Order Mass Cancel Report <r>